I Will Be Waiting For Your Return

Honesah Hoononee Keemo was a Lord of the Rings Mary Sue with the dubious distinction of being killed twice; once by Agents Jaster and Threnody and once by Agents Fireblade, Keitaro, and Kali.

Character History
Honesah was a Pegacorn, a winged humanoid with wings, a unicorn horn, horizontally-striped hair, and hooves. Her people battled black dragons known as crimps. She ate a memory leaf and forgot who she was. She eventually fell in love with Legolas and had a winged unicorn "colty." She would eventually turn into a cat anthro, but in neither version of the fic did the PPC let her get to that point.

Character Deaths
Jaster mauled her in the form of a warg, and Threnody's cousin Harmony mangled the colty. Fireblade, Keitaro, and Kali fed her to Smaug and adoped the colty.