Talk:Uncanon

"Uncanon" doesn't look at all right to me. "Non-canonical" looks much more accurate. Anyone know for definite? Paddlebrains - 12.01 24/4/08
 * Well, we've been using uncanon for years... :P Seriously, the distinction is between non-canonical material, ie everything beyond the actual canon, so all fanfic, most reference guides, etc, and uncanon, which is contrary to the Canon. Legolas being 2,931 years old is non-canonical, because it comes from Movie guides, whereas Legolas being 16 years old is uncanon, because it makes no sense in the context of the books. Huinesoron, 16:25, 24th April 2008 (GMT)
 * Ah, I shall stand corrected then. And I'll try to rein in the twitching whenever I see "uncanon". Paddlebrains - 14.25 25/4/08