Talk:Stargate

I think that Stargate should have a disambiguation page, and be split into its constiuent parts. Stargate movie, Stargate SG-1, Stargate Atlantis, and Stargate Universe. All of the missions, I think, are for Atlantis. I would be willing to make the pages for everything but Universe. With all the new pages going in, it seems wrong to have a fandom with several missions in it be a note at the bottom of another fandom.Miah 79 16:05, June 18, 2010 (UTC)
 * At the moment, they're all listed by continuum, such as Doctor Who and Torchwood listed together, and Bufffy and Angel listed together, with links back to the main page. My two cents--I don't know whether the different Stargate shows/movies are different enough to be considered different continua. Even if they're not, it makes sense to differentiate between them via either separate pages or else different sections on the main Stargate page. If there are separate pages, they should probably link to each other fairly plainly so that all the information from the continuum could be easily found. Maybe try renaming this page to just "Stargate", then different sections for the different programs, and a note on the missions to show which Stargate the mission takes place in?--Chaoticidealism 21:35, June 18, 2010 (UTC)


 * Hmm, I think who ever listed the Torchwood and Doctor Who missions in one wiki article didn't really want to go into the missions and found out which it was. I think I will set that straight, because there, it's the same situation as here, because I think there are actually more missions into TW than into DW. Torchwood does have its own page(s). Indemaat 22:10, June 18, 2010 (UTC)
 * I think they are sufficiently different to have their own pages that link back. The fans do not necessarily crossover.  You notice that IndeMaat said on the mini discussion that she's never watched SG-1, and that I said I would not do the page for Universe (one of the new agents listed Universe on their fandoms, so maybe that person could do it).  If we can't make separate pages for them, then at the least please change the title of this one to Stargate.  It does still make sense to list them together on the Complete List, since all the others with similar situations are.Miah 79 23:40, June 18, 2010 (UTC)